this must be the place....goin strong , yeah baby!!!

Showing posts with label Pitchfork Media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pitchfork Media. Show all posts

Monday, July 12, 2010

M.I.A. Pitchfork review

In other news....man, I just saw this review.

"Right or wrong, the social contract is simple: If you bring the hits, we'll put up with your shit.

With /\/\/\Y/\, M.I.A. has broken that contract. And she could not have chosen a worse time to do it. The album comes not long after a New York Times Magazine cover story that portrayed her as a pretentious, truffle fries-eating phony spouting radical politics at odds with her extremely comfortable lifestyle. The piece was devastating to her credibility, and her childish response-- putting the author's cell number on Twitter-- only made matters worse."


What a hatchet job! I'm not even talking about the album, I have no idea what it sounds like, but this "cleverly worded" bit about the NYTs article, that is just straight up character assassination. Really brutal, you can't like to see that. A total lack of regard for presenting the facts of the story, and trying to continue the spread of this rumor about some goddamn elitist French Fries ("have you seen the price of arugula lately?" what if we had had 4 more years of a Republican president because of those words, like that could have been the Swift Boat moment of 2008).

Not that journalism and music journalism should ever be confused, but for those of you unaware, the NYT journalist ordered these French Fries and then in her article painted M.I.A. as this "truffle oil french fry eating" elitist hypocrite blah blah blah. I'm tired of this shit. For the follow up, Maya had the whole interview on tape and released it to defend herself and now pitchfork is probably taking somebodies $$$ under the table to write this shit.

Fuck off Pfork, you guys just were downgraded from being controversy creating opportunists to being on the wrong side of the war in my book.

Read More......

Thursday, April 16, 2009

This Just In....

This morning the website pitchfork.com awarded the Radiohead albums "Ok Computer" and "The Bends" 10.0s as well as their coveted "best new music" tag. I just hope it helps the band sell some records!

In other news....
Pablo Honey received a lowly 5.4 :(

Read More......

Friday, February 27, 2009

Mildly Amusing Booking -- the moderately different (?) pitchfork rant

REPLACE THESE STARS WITH HOMEPAGE SUMMARY<-->

This is sorta rich, I think...

Pitchfork just released their SXSW party schedule. I don't know every single band they booked, but I'd like to take a stab at some of the logic behind this booking, and do what will probably only take 5 minutes worth of "myspace research" in order to throw an educated guess at the rest. This is to be a sort of "why am I not surprised" in the tradition of attempting to guess to the spot their year end best-of list, which I recall a few of us did to a somewhat hysterical degree of accuracy, the proof of which likes somewhere in this blogs archives. ("But anyone could've!" exactly.)
REPLACE THESE STARS WITH FULL POST<-->

But first, my historical emotions on a website so beloved in these hallow halls that Noggin wrote a simple crack to automatically change its spelling in order we not refer them traffic via search engines algorithms (nerd alert!!)

The complaints about pitchfork in my mind have always been the same (and at this point you really have to start with the complaints). -- 1. They don't really ever go out on a limb, 2. while they explore what's going on in other cultures, going as far as to employ boots on the ground aka 3rd party bloggers, they often turn a blind eye to what is going on in the American underground, opting to cover what's going on in what I'll call "the American-underground-music-industry" instead, 3. they periodically write unfair reviews, both overly positive and negative, as a speculative and Machiavellian practice to create a buzz loop which will in turn "prove" their own relevance, as well as help maintain their ad revenues, often to the detriment of bands,(which like the American worker we will call "hard-working" for the sake of rhetorical flourish) and finally, 4. that, even though they have to be aware of everything mentioned above, they still manage to believe their own shit, which in turn causes them to "miss the point" more often than probably should be strictly necessary.

And that strikes me as just so crass, and frankly, unnecessary. It's as if they don't recognize real rock and roll exists, and so they organize themselves around some bizarre Warholian reproduction of it, to fill a void that doesn't exist. And while you can't just ignore what was going on in Britian in the 60s (as the classical narrative would tell it) as central to any historical retelling you would find in a History of Rock and Roll class at a mediocre 4 year university, the hierarchical promotion of the Beatlemania hero-aspect of it is counter productive to a concept of rock-and-roll-as-living-art (its been said a million times, but why rate albums from 0.0-10.0 in the first place?) It's like overturning Roe v Wade...you just can't ignore precedent, and the laughability factor comes in when you consider the level of canonization Pitchfork affords to 80s alternative.

But rock and roll is alive and well, and its not going anywhere, so i should probably unwad my panties and shut up about this particular matter, because its such a straw man to profess the DIY ethic and waste time attack the music industry on any level. But I think it can still be understood as a more proper Yin to the DIY circuits Yang than say, Capitol Records. The proverbial darkness without which light can't exist.

I am somewhat remiss at this point to have neglected to mention that especially during 2003-4 when I was first in college, pitchfork turned me on to a hell of a lot of music I wouldn't have been exposed to otherwise, including from college radio. Their best tool for me (in conjunction with allmusic.com) was their searchable database of reviews from the past few years, which by the way is no longer easily accessible, and which has inexplicably in my view seen deletions. The stuff they were covering at the time was also really exciting, and the majority of what made their year end list was good shit (note: The Rapture-Echoes was still head-scratchingly their 2003 pick for best album, speculatively because they were trying to push that [*cough* New York] record in order to appear as ultra hip as possible. Oops, called that one wrong.}

But I don't think they really know what's going on anymore. I mean, they don't cover the DIY circuit at all south of Baltimore/D.C, except some West Coast stuff. If you were them, trying to do what they do, wouldn't you actively pursue this? Fuckin Yankees! And they can pay lip service in the reviews but to me these SXSW shows they book (and to a lesser extent their festival) is the damning evidence that its as much them not knowing what they are doing as anything else.

Which is to say you can pay lip service in the reviews, but that's not even really where their focus lies these day, and booking is really the ultimate test, because you have to take sides.


The full Pitchfork SXSW schedule:

12:00 - Girls (Emo's Jr.)
12:30 - The Mae Shi (Emo's)
1:00 - Little Boots (Emo's Jr.)
1:30 - Max Tundra (Emo's)
2:00 - The Pains of Being Pure at Heart (Emo's Jr.)
2:30 - Woods (Emo's)
3:00 - School of Seven Bells (Emo's Jr.)
3:30 - Wavves (Emo's)
4:00 - Dirty Projectors (Emo's Jr.)
4:30 - King Khan & the Shrines (Emo's)
5:00 - A-Trak/Major Lazer [ft. Diplo] (Emo's Jr.)
5:30 - Department of Eagles (Emo's)


Keep in mind, pitchfork could have gotten WHOEVER THEY WANTED and run this show HOWEVER THEY WANTED at ANY VENUE THEY WANTED, and yet they make THE SAFEST PICKS POSSIBLE WITH A CLEAR REGIONAL BIAS. OK, so who'd they get for their big "were the best, come to our party" rock show (and it goes without saying, I wonder which of these bands is getting paid and which aren't).

The things that stick out about this show to me: 1. Where are all these bands from, oh yeah, New York, LA and San Fransisco. 2. The inclusion of Woods and Wavves. I don't know much about these bands other than to tell you they have already for all intensive purposes "blown up." They were on Todd P (influential NYC promoters) email list in Capital letters for like months for about 4 different shows, which is highly unusual for his mailing list. I also bought a Vivian Girls 7" that is on Woodsist, which, as I was putting 2 and 2 together, is a hip NYCcentric label run by the band Woods. Cool! They are probably cool dudes, and these are bands I would like to see over SXSW if I get a chance...its not the bands, its the regionalism and conservativeness masquerading as edginess that bothers me.

School of Seven Bells is a Brooklyn band soon to open for Black Moth Super Rainbow. I for some reason thought this band was from San Fransisco and related to Deerhoof. Even without the BMSR dates, I would have bet this band has a booking agent, being as though the other shows they are playing over SXSW are at Mohawk (Rhapsody daytime party), Transmission's new Radio Room (Mojo party), this pithfork show at Emos, and, hey, throw in a show at the Urban Outfitters, why not, Bloc Party (remember them?) played there.

The Pains of Being Pure at Heart (NYC) to me are an interestingly obvious pick (couldn't get Vivian Girls?) Pitchfork has been pushing this storyline like this whole sound is in a revival right now, because they found a band in England that sounds the same (as if there is any creative England --> USA musical interaction right now), but what they say it's a revival of is like Cherry Red 80s indie pop. One band they bring up is The Shop Assistants, and while I only know of, have listened to and enjoyed that band specifically because of press related to these "revival" bands, its sort of ignoring the fact that Cherry Red was the no-respect bastard little brother to Rough Trade in its own time, and while The Shop Assistants wrote some cool songs, Cherry Red got no respect at least partially BECAUSE THEIR ROSTER WASN'T THAT GREAT. So it stands to reason that the non-top dog doing this sound may also be NOT THAT GREAT. But I haven't seen em

Hard to ever complain about the Dirty Projectors (NYC) on a bill, regardless of whether or not its a "safe" pick, but if you're giving this tastemaker/regionalism arguement of mine weight, don't forget this is the same band that at one time used as a press quote (I think from 2005ish) "'The best band in NYC right now' -Todd P"

Then follow that with, shockingly obviously in 2008, a big garage band. Couldn't get the Black Lips? Oh no shit? King Khan, really going out on a limb there. Follow that with big name party DJs (which you stick at Emo's inside???)....and then follow that with Dept. of Eagles (NYC), guys known for their use of texture on a completely unsuitable sound system (less suitable than Emo's Inside even.)

So, pah, I laugh at you Pitchfork!!!! I'd rather go see those bands at the Todd P Mrs. Bea's shows anyways, DUH.

Oh and assuming no bad shit goes dow, our shows are gonna be the shit this year. Like, next level the shit for real. Still getting the slots in...



I love you all

Read More......

Friday, December 19, 2008

A Milli

So A Milli was probably the most played song this year. I guess Lollipop might give it a run for it's money, but A Milli will probably be the single that people think of when they remember Tha Carter 3. Here's a sweet remix of it by Flying Lotus. I'm posting it because I thought I was really tired of A Milli, but this seems to breathe a little bit of new air into it. Even though the remix is probably three months old.

Flying Lotus - Robo Tussin (ft. Lil Wayne)

(divshare)

In other news, Tha Carter 3 placed #11 in Pitchfork's top albums of the year. I was pretty surprised not to see it in the top 10. I didn't want to write much about their list, but I am going to. Here's my quick rundown of the albums on their top 10 that are worth saying anything about.



#1. Fleet Foxes? Haven't listed to them, don't care.
#2. Portishead? Are you fucking kidding me? I laughed out loud once or twice while listening to this album.
#3. No Age? Haven't listened to them, don't care.
#4. Cut Copy. I listened to this album twice in a row when I first heard it. It's great, deserves it's spot.
#7. Vampire Weekend. Really?
#8. M83. Are you fucking kidding me? Again, this album is laughable. I feel like people who dig this album are just trying to prove that they like 80s pop music.
#9. Hercules and Love Affair. Deserve to be higher, although they did get the nod for best single of the year.

They put the Arthur Russell comp at 30 or so, which I don't agree with and also surprised me given the amount of love they have been sending his way lately. Another big surprise to me was the inclusion of The Dodos record as an honorable mention. I thought it would be top 10 for sure, at least top 20.

I totally sympathize with the Tiny Mix Tapes article that Chris posted a few days ago. I just don't give a shit about most of this "best new music".

Read More......

Monday, December 8, 2008

Listen to Criticism

Marathonpacks is a music criticism blog written by Eric Harvey. He writes a column for Pitchfork titled Silent Party, and also reviews records for them on occasion. Today he made an interesting post about his part in a new method of selling records online.

The record label Asthmatic Kitty has adopted a "post-In Rainbows" record pricing strategy based on Pitchfork's rating system. An album by Granmpall Jookabox just received a 5.4 from Mr. Harvey, and thusly Asthmatic Kitty will sell the album online with a pricetag of $5.40 for 54 hours.

In the past one could have said that a band's financial success would be very influenced by coverage on Pitchfork, but this is taking it way too far. Although the sale price is temporary, it is still abominable. With this marketing plan, Pitchfork's rating defines the value of the artifact for sale. I can't believe the band agreed to this, it's pretty nightmarish.

Read More......

Saturday, October 4, 2008

Incredible...

...the way you can watch these things as they are happening. This is a rant, so it will inevitably include leaps of logic and easily misunderstood language. Be prepared. It's a little piece on how the music industry works, which is something every citizen in America should be aware of, IMO. It's a case study, and the source material is The Vivian Girls.

Pitchfork just reviewed the new Vivian Girls record and started with this line:
"In a year when Brooklyn buzz travels around the world at lightspeed, you can probably count on one hand the number of new bands that, when the hype settles, are more than inconsequential collections of postures and exhausted second-hand styles."

I have a one word answer to that: Yes.

You could read the rest of the review, but to me, this first line reads as "you are going to accuse us of this, and we are going to let you know we are aware of your forthcoming accusations, and use them as a straw-man argument to debunk them as they pertain to this band, even though that's not the sort of thing you can really debunk in a record review."

It realy strikes at values, I guess, but I have a number of theories involving this "Vivian Girls explosion" (which i'm calling pitchfork best new music a culmination of.) Before I continue any further, let me say I don't think they are bad. The point of this "article" doesn't related to how good or bad they actually are, outside of the fact that they are not IMO that super fucking awesome. And i feel comfortable saying that as someone who has only seen their live material on the internet and hasn't heard their whole record, given partially to the fact that what i saw of them live wasn't interactive in a way that would suggest the experience live is different than the record really, and also due to the fact that their "LP" is TWENTY TWO minutes short, so having heard their myspace tracks, and from the live footage, its possible I have heard their whole record.

The point of this article for me is more why "The Vivian Girls" instead of The Strange Boys (also on In The Red), The Barbaras (In The Red/Goner), or The Oh Sees (just to name the bands that off the top of my head I think are better, doing a similar sound for longer, been working harder for longer, and not immediately sucessful in the same way)? This is not to mention the bands that have done the garage sound recently who I'm not familiar with, but know I should be, a list which would include Reigning Sound, and I know there are some others that I should be able to think of and just can't.

the short answer:
1) The Vivian Girls are from Brooklyn, where the music media industry literally lives, works, and breaths.
2) There are 2 hot girls in the band.
3) They have a good single, with an accompanying music video.
4) There are certain elements of known quantities about them: they will be able to sell records (see items 1-3), they play a sound that has an established national scene, and they have buzz, which is related to items 1-3 and also a considerable about to the first half of item 4.

what is buzz? Buzz is when a bunch of people see a band and say to themselves "this band is going to be a much bigger band than they are currently." not "this is a great band that no one knows about!" If 95% of people in the music industry literally did not know the difference between good and bad music, they would be saying the same thing about Yellow Fever, starting, oh, 9 months ago. I think Yellow Fever is going to be fine (from an "industry standpoint" to totally seperate the commercial side from the art side...im literally rolling my eyes as i type this)

I should also mention, another reason this example in particular strikes a chord with me has to do with the fact that its garage, which is a) not that hard to do a shitty job of, witness the wave of shitty bands inspired by The Black Lips and then again I've been told by Jay Retard, and b) this current garage revival has created its own circut which it is possible will now become infested with money-grubbers and kill a lot of creativity, and also, even though it may have only been a matter of time, I think Vivian Girls is going to be the band to do it.

So why not those other bands? 1. geography. 2. they aren't hot girls, and certainly not in this typically American early 20s definition of what hot is way

Anyways, this probably isn't all I have to say on the subject, but I gotta go see a show, so anything else will have to wait (I'm going to see Golden Triangle, who may be one of those 5 bands that is not all hype from Brooklyn...I'll find out soon enough...and also Quintron and Miss Pussycat)

Read More......

Thursday, April 3, 2008

Dear Chris (why can't we be friends?)

Dear Chris,

It's me Pitchfork Media.
Come on. I'm not that bad!
You know you don't believe those things you said about me. Deep down you know those American Apparel leggings are smoking hot. Especially when girls are skinny from all the coke!

You've gotta change with the times man, you know? Like when the Bee-Gees jumped on disco and jive talked it into the American mainstream. We're just like that! You think people would want to live in places like Brooklyn, or maybe a little closer to home, East Austin, if they thought only black and Mexican people lived there? Of course not! We need to let our readers know that while there may be minorities, these burgeoning cultural centers are full of coked out American Apparel hunnies fucking in the bushes behind raging house parties full of DJs playing Pitchfork Recommended French electro releases.
And you know what, we like to bring our hipster masses down a notch or two sometimes. It's important to remind them that they don't decide what they like, we do. And once they think that they know what they like, we switch it up on them and decide that shit isn't cool anymore, and it's just like our readers decided it for themselves!

I know that you think house shows are cool. We think so too! You know that band you had play at your house the other day? Well we like them. We like that band that played a month before too. And those guys that used to live at your house, like three or four years ago? We like their band too! We even put a picture of you on our website!

It's true, maybe I don't know what you're listening to these days, but we try our best. We've been working on getting an interview with Prince for years! He just won't talk to us!

We can't put on house shows, it just wouldn't work. So we try pretty hard to put together the most affordable this-side-of-free music festival around with bands that would generally be listed in small to small-medium font on a professionally designed fsetival flyer. Do you know how many of those flyers we have to embed into HTML every day? Like two. We know the bands really well that hang out in that font size.

But maybe you have noticed a change in the past few years. We used to only cover those small to medium fonted bands. Now we care about Rhianna! We're trying! We don't want you to think we're snobs, we want to do like the common people. We hear songs on the radio we like every once in awhile. We usually apologize for them, but it's called journalism.

Now the MTV thing was a low-blow and you know it. Especially on the eve of our pitchfork.tv launch. We're not going to have hipster elimidate, we're talking the Pixies! Liars! And you know those parties you were talking about, well Death By Stereo has a D-I-Y party space, and we're going to be giving you a personal interweb tour!

Please Chris. Remember when you would get all hot and bothered by a 9.0? We used to mean something to you and we want to mean it again. Did you see The Dodos at the SXSW show at the Communications Courtyard? We're jizzing all over them! Recommended New Music, Forkcast, 8.5 rating, tour itineraries! Remember reading tour itineraries? You loved it! You have to admit that our use of symbols to designate the intersecting itineraries of bands is downright practical, you know in your heart that it is.

So I guess you don't want to fool around anymore. That's cool, I understand I have been putting on the pounds and I'm not as quick a read anymore. I know you'd rather be intercoursing with more relevant community focused zines or talking to those cool older people that you, well, didn't know a few years ago. It's fine, we don't have to make the same streaming non-pornographic internet love that we used to. But you know, you could, like, come over and hang out and maybe we could watch a movie or something.

-Pitchfork Media

Read More......